An employee used the company card for personal expenses: what to do next
It is more common than it feels when it happens to you. In Emburse's surveys, about a quarter of employees admit to passing a personal purchase off as a business one at some point (Emburse, 2024 and 2026). Most of those are small, once, and would be repaid without argument if anyone asked. A few are a pattern. Your job in the first week is to find out which, without turning either into a bigger problem than it is.
First, separate the three cases
A mistake. Wrong card at the till, a personal subscription that was meant to be on their own card, a one-off they already feel bad about. The person usually says so the moment you ask. Response: repayment, a reminder of the rule, done.
A habit. Small personal charges every month: lunches on days with no client, the odd Amazon order, fuel on a Sunday. Nobody decided to steal; the line just moved. Response: repayment of everything you can identify, a written warning, and a change in how the card is reviewed so the line moves back.
A scheme. Charges disguised as business with made-up attendees or altered receipts, goods delivered home and resold, gift cards bought in quantity. This is theft, and it is the case where the person's first answer will be a story. Response: stop, gather the record, and bring in your lawyer or accountant before the next conversation.
You will not always know which case you have until you have asked. That is why the first step is the same in all three.
Step 1. Ask, in writing, before you conclude anything
One short email per charge or group of charges, the kind described in How to ask an employee about a company card charge: the charge as it appears, one specific question, a date to reply by, and the easy out of "Personal by mistake? Reply 'Personal, I'll repay' and we'll close it."
Do this even when you are sure. A written question and a written answer is the record you will want later, and offering the easy out turns most mistakes into a closed case in one reply.
Step 2. Read the answer against the charge
- Does the explanation fit the merchant, the amount and the date? "Client dinner" on a Sunday evening at a restaurant near the person's home is possible, but it wants names.
- Is there a receipt, and does it match? A card slip with no items is not a receipt. A receipt whose total differs from the charge needs a reason.
- Does the same explanation keep appearing? One "team lunch" is normal. Eight in a quarter with no team is not.
If the answer holds, close it and move on. You asked, they answered, the record exists. That is the system working.
Step 3. Repayment
For a mistake or a habit, ask for the full amount of every personal charge you can identify, by a date, and confirm it in writing. Two practical points:
- Do not deduct from wages without checking. In most US states a deduction needs the employee's written agreement, and in some it is restricted further; several other countries forbid it outright. A bank transfer or a cheque from the employee is cleaner than a payroll deduction, and the written agreement to repay is the document that matters.
- Keep the list. Date, merchant, amount, the person's explanation, the repayment date. If it ever becomes a dispute, this list is the case.
Step 4. The card
A single honest mistake does not need the card taken away. A habit does, at least for a period: a lower limit, a block on the merchant categories involved, or a card that is held by the manager and handed out per purchase. Most business card portals let you change an employee card's limit without reissuing it, and many also let you block categories such as cash withdrawals; check what yours offers.
If the person leaves, cancel the card on their last day, not at the end of the month. Charges after an exit date are a recurring finding in audits for a reason.
Step 5. Decide whether it is a disciplinary matter
A reasonable ladder, which most company card policies already contain in some form:
| What happened | Response |
|---|---|
| One personal charge, admitted, repaid | Repayment and a reminder. No file note needed. |
| Repeated personal charges, or a policy breach after a reminder | Repayment, a written warning, limits on the card. |
| Personal spending disguised as business | Repayment, card withdrawn, a formal disciplinary process under your employment rules. |
| Altered or fabricated receipts, resold goods, collusion with a merchant | Dismissal is usual. Preserve the records, take advice, consider reporting. |
Two rules keep this fair and defensible. Apply the same ladder to everyone, including people you like and people you need. And write the policy down before you need it: a ladder that exists only in your head looks like improvisation when it is tested.
Step 6. Fix the review, not just the person
The charge got through because nobody looked at the statement line by line, or because the person knew nobody would. That is the part you can change for everyone at once:
- Every charge gets looked at, every month. Not a sample.
- Every doubtful charge gets a question within days, from you, in writing.
- Every cardholder has signed a short policy that says both of the above.
People spend differently when they know someone will ask. That is not cynicism about your staff; it is the cheapest control you have.
Related: Nine red flags on a company card statement and A company credit card policy for sales reps.