How to ask an employee about a company card charge (with the email template)
You have a charge on the statement that you cannot place. Nine times out of ten there is a plain explanation, and the person would give it in one sentence if asked. The difficulty is asking in a way that gets the sentence without making a good employee feel accused, and without letting a bad one talk around it.
The answer is a short written question, sent the same way every time, to everyone. Written, because you want the answer next to the charge later. The same for everyone, because fairness is what makes the question routine instead of personal.
What a good question contains
- The charge, exactly as it appears. Merchant, amount, date, and the last four digits of the card. The person may hold two cards and will not remember a Tuesday in September without help.
- One specific question. Not "please explain" but "what was this for, and who attended?" Specific questions get specific answers; vague ones get "business expense".
- A date to reply by. Three working days is reasonable. Without a date, the question joins the pile.
- The two easy outs. "If it was personal by mistake, reply 'Personal, I'll repay' and we'll close it." and "If you didn't make this charge, reply 'Not me' and we'll block the card." Most awkward cases end here, cheaply, because you offered the exit.
- What the answer should include, when a receipt or a list of attendees is needed. Say so now, not in a second email.
What to leave out
- Any theory. Do not say what you think happened. The moment you write "this looks personal", the reply is a defence instead of an answer.
- The policy lecture. One line, if any: "our card policy asks for a receipt for meals". The full policy is for the sign-off, not for every question.
- A copy to anyone else. The first question goes to the cardholder alone. Copying HR or their manager on a routine question escalates it before you know whether there is anything to escalate.
The template
This is the wording CardCurb sends; use it as it is.
Subject: Quick question: Steakhouse 55, $486.00 on Oct 14
Hi Dana,
A quick question about a charge on your company card ending 4417:
14 Oct · Steakhouse 55 · $486.00 → Who attended, and which company did each guest represent? Please attach the itemised receipt.
Please reply by Friday 17 October — just answer this email.
Personal by mistake? Reply "Personal – I'll repay" — we'll close it.
Thanks, Alex
That is the whole message. It is short because the person is busy and because length reads as suspicion. Notice there is no "I noticed" and no "can you justify": the question is about the charge, not about them.
For several charges at once
Number them, ask one question per charge or per group of similar charges, and say that answering some now and the rest later is fine. People answer the easy ones immediately, which leaves you with the short list that matters.
Three card charges need a quick answer:
- 3 Oct · Amazon · $212.60 — What was ordered, and where was it delivered?
- 9 Oct · Shell · $88.40 — Which vehicle was this for?
- 11 Oct · Netflix · $15.99 — Which work task is this subscription used for?
Reply with the number and your answer. By Friday, thanks — Alex
If the question comes from you, not from accounting
Send it from your own address, signed with your name. People answer their manager; a question from accounting or from a system address is easy to park. The downside is that your inbox becomes the filing cabinet, which is the part worth automating: the question should go out in your name, and the answer should land next to the charge, not in a thread you have to find again in March.
When there is no answer
Silence is an answer too. After the reply-by date, one reminder. After the reminder, the matter goes to the person's manager with the charge and the two unanswered emails attached, which is a much stronger position than a verbal "I asked him about it once". Keep that sequence the same for everyone, and nobody can say they were singled out.
Related: Nine red flags on a company card statement and An employee used the company card for personal expenses: what to do next.